Start with one project brief
Use the same brief for every provider. State the workflow, current system, desired output, buyer time, restricted information, review owner and decision date.
Fill in one column per proposal
Record the first paid deliverable, scope, buyer effort, test, handoff, ongoing charges and exit terms. Mark each row stated, excluded, optional or unknown.
| Term | Proposal A | Proposal B |
|---|---|---|
| First paid deliverable and exclusions | ____ | ____ |
| Workflow count and affected systems | ____ | ____ |
| Preparation, meeting and review time | ____ | ____ |
| Configuration and custom work | ____ | ____ |
| Acceptance conditions and fallback | ____ | ____ |
| Documentation, training and handoff | ____ | ____ |
| Software, API, telephony and hosting | ____ | ____ |
| Included support and later charges | ____ | ____ |
| Account control, data and exit terms | ____ | ____ |
| Payment milestones and optional follow-on | ____ | ____ |
Compare the same period
Example: $2,000 setup plus $120 a month totals $2,720 over six months before extra usage and support. A $4,500 build with software billed separately has a known subtotal of $4,500 and an unresolved running cost.
Check supporting evidence
For any case-study result, record the source, baseline, measured period and limits. Ask the provider to confirm the unresolved terms against your brief.